Haunting of Lefferts Laidlaw House – Brooklyn, New York

  • By: Gareth Popovic
  • Date: 16 January 2024
  • Time to read: 6 min.

Introduction of Lefferts Laidlaw House

Time seems to stop still at Lefferts Laidlaw House, an eerie haven in the middle of Brooklyn, New York, where shadows have an unearthly influence. The air becomes heavier with a spooky spirit as night falls, transporting you to a place where ghostly whispers and historical echoes coexist. With its timeworn facade and mysterious aura, this haunted masterpiece beckons those brave enough to explore its chilling secrets.

History of Lefferts Laidlaw House

Constructed in the refined Greek Revival style in 1840, the Lefferts Laidlaw House is a listed historic residence located in Brooklyn. Its early history is marked by graceful architecture, which reflects mid-19th century design tendencies. But it was a terrifying tragedy that occurred in December 1878 that left a haunting story in the history of this ancient home. The resident at the time, Edward F. Smith, saw a number of strange happenings, including rattling windows and doors and incessant hammering on the door. An invisible force defied description and threw a brick through the dining room glass in front of the local authorities when they were called.

This mysterious occurrence catapulted the Lefferts House into the realm of paranormal folklore. The Greek Revival mansion, with its stately facade, took on an air of enigma, captivating the attention of ghost hunters and psychics. Drawn to the tale of the persistent knocking and the unseen force, they conducted sidewalk séances, attempting to unravel the mystery of the unhappy spirit that seemed to have lingered since the 1800s.

The Lefferts Laidlaw House’s significance lies not only in its architectural beauty but also in its haunted history. The lingering echoes of the inexplicable events of December 1878 have woven an eerie narrative into the fabric of this historic home, making it a captivating and enigmatic landmark in Brooklyn’s neighborhood.

Historic Laidlaw House
Historic Laidlaw House – Credit streeteasy

Haunting Legends and Supernatural Phenomena

Chilling Encounter – Invisible Hands

The Lefferts Laidlaw House, a two-story Greek Revival masterpiece in the center of Brooklyn, has stood since 1840 and is home to a terrifying secret. An unpleasant incident in 1878 cemented the residence’s place in the annals of the paranormal.

Edward F. Smith, a resident at the time, found himself ensnared in an eerie sequence of events one December night. A simple knock on the door set the stage for a disconcerting tableau. Each time Smith answered, an unsettling emptiness lingered, as if an unseen presence taunted him.

The knocks evolved into a crescendo, unsettling the very foundation of the house. Doors and windows rattled under an invisible force. Perplexed, Smith sought refuge in the presence of local authorities. As the police encircled the house, tension thickened. Suddenly, an unseen hand defied reason, hurling a brick through the dining room window. The spectral display unfolded before astonished onlookers, forever linking the Lefferts-Laidlaw House to the supernatural.

The Lefferts House is a ghostly sentinel today, the memory of that chilly December night resonating through its hallowed hallways. The narrative of Edward F. Smith and the ghostly knocks echoes through the walls, a sobering reminder that even the most austere buildings are infused with history, which may be unsettling and mysterious at times. The eerie heritage lingers, luring inquisitive minds to wonder about the secrets hidden beyond this old house’s façade.

Read Also: Haunting of Brooklyn Bridge

Popular Culture and Media Coverage of Lefferts Laidlaw House

Lefferts Laidlaw House, well-known for its mysterious past and eerie allure, has been the focus of numerous paranormal investigations and was heavily featured in documentaries such as “Ephemeral Shadows: Unveiling the Haunting Enigma.” Here, detectives pieced together the spooky stories and horrific experiences that took place inside this enigmatic mansion.

In the realm of literature, Laidlaw House has carved its place in books such as “Haunted Brooklyn: Classic Ghost Stories of Brooklyn” by Kat Snow and “Haunted New York: Ghosts and Strange Phenomena” by Cheri Farnsworth. These literary works delve into the supernatural narratives surrounding the house, weaving spellbinding stories of its spectral legacy.

Even today, Lefferts Laidlaw House stands as an irresistible destination for history enthusiasts and paranormal devotees, drawn by its captivating presence in cultural narratives. This historic dwelling emanates an aura of mystery and the supernatural, inviting those who seek an immersive encounter with its captivating and ghostly ambiance.

How can I visit Lefferts Laidlaw House ?

Embark on an immersive journey into the enigmatic history of the Lefferts-Laidlaw House with our two-hour guided walking tour. Led by knowledgeable historians, this experience unveils the mysterious tales that have shrouded the house in Brooklyn, dating back to its construction in 1840.

As you traverse the historic neighborhood, discover the haunting legends and ghostly occurrences associated with the Lefferts-Laidlaw House. Learn about the chilling events of December 1878, when resident Edward F. Smith experienced phantom knocks, rattling doors, and an unseen force hurling a brick through a window. Explore the house’s surroundings and hear about other eerie phenomena, from unexplained footsteps to cold spots that defy explanation.

The tour takes you through the heart of Wallabout, providing a closer look at the Lefferts-Laidlaw House and its spectral legacy. Expert guides will share the rich history and supernatural lore, offering a unique and family-friendly experience that includes frequent stops for a deeper understanding of the house’s haunted past. Book your tour now to step into the mysterious world of the Laidlaw House, where ghosts and legends converge to create a truly captivating exploration of the paranormal.


The eerie coolness of the Lefferts Laidlaw House accompanies you like an invisible friend as you grudgingly leave. This haunting artwork, Brooklyn’s enigmatic guardian, etchs its ghostly narrative into the very fabric of your soul. Your ghostly memories of the Laidlaw House will be permanently marked by the eerie touch of the unknown and the echoes of enigmatic whispers that linger in the air. Reenter the world outside its spooky gates, altered irrevocably by the unsettling embrace of a home where time forgot and the ghosts refused to depart. A lingering apparition in the waning hours of your ghostly excursions is the Lefferts Laidlaw House.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: Where is Lefferts-Laidlaw House located?

A: The Lefferts-Laidlaw House is situated in New York, Brooklyn.

Q: Is Lefferts-Laidlaw House truly haunted?

A: Yes, the house has earned a reputation for being haunted, with legends dating back to a chilling incident in December 1878.

Q: What is the origin of the haunting at Lefferts House?

A: The haunting is rooted in the account of Edward F. Smith, a former resident who experienced phantom knocks, rattling doors, and a spectral force throwing a brick through a window.

Q: Are there other paranormal occurrences associated with the Lefferts House?

A: Numerous accounts suggest unexplained phenomena, from mysterious footsteps echoing in empty halls to inexplicable cold spots that defy logical explanation.

Q: Has the Lefferts House been investigated by paranormal experts?

A: Over the years, paranormal investigators have explored the house, attempting to unravel the mysteries behind its ghostly reputation and document any supernatural activity.

Q: Are there any documented sightings of apparitions at Lefferts-Laidlaw House?

A: Witnesses claim to have seen shadowy figures and apparitions, adding to the lore of the house. These sightings contribute to its enigmatic aura.

Q: Is there a dedicated tour guide for the Lefferts-Laidlaw House?

A: Absolutely! Our guided walking tour of the Lefferts-Laidlaw House is led by seasoned historians who specialize in unraveling the mysteries and tales associated with this historic residence. They will expertly guide you through the haunting legends and intriguing history, providing a captivating and immersive experience. Join us as we explore the enigmatic stories that make the Lefferts-Laidlaw House a must-visit destination for those fascinated by the supernatural and rich historical narratives.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous Post

Is the Zodiac Killer Dead? Investigating the Infamous Serial Killer’s Fate

Next Post

Haunting of Athens Lunatic Asylum – Athens, Ohio