The Most Haunted Houses in Indiana

  • By: Timothy Rose
  • Date: 7 December 2023
  • Time to read: 9 min.

The most chilling tales often lurk in quiet places, and Indiana, with its unassuming charm, is home to some of the most hair-raising haunted houses in the nation. These eerie abodes, scattered across the Hoosier State, each tell a story of unsettled spirits and inexplicable occurrences. From the infamous Demon House in Gary, which became a focal point of supernatural studies, to the unsettling Whispers Estate in Mitchell, known for its mysterious sounds and ghostly apparitions, Indiana’s haunted houses are steeped in lore. These historic homes, like the Ruthmere Mansion in Elkhart and the ominous Hannah House in Indianapolis, are not just old buildings; they are archives of the paranormal, brimming with tales that challenge the bravest of hearts to uncover the truths hidden within their walls.

One of the most haunted houses in Indiana is the James Allison Mansion. This home, which is in Indianapolis, was constructed in 1903 and has a lengthy history of eerie behavior. Inside the home, visitors have mentioned seeing ghosts, hearing unsettling noises, and experiencing a sense of dread. The mansion is a favorite haunt for ghost investigators and has been on various paranormal investigative shows.

James Allison Mansion - Credit edpopcheff
James Allison Mansion – Credit edpopcheff

Hannah House is yet another eerie building in Indiana. This mansion, which is in Indianapolis, was constructed in 1858 and originally served as a stop on the Underground Railroad. Visitors have claimed to hear weird noises throughout the house and saw the ghost of a young girl wearing a white dress. Currently a museum, the house is accessible to the general public for tours. Whether you believe in ghosts or not, you’re guaranteed to have a frightening time at the Hannah House.

Lets’s dive into these in a bit more detail.

James Allison Mansion

The James Allison Mansion in Indianapolis, Indiana, is a structure with a storied past and an eerie reputation. Built between 1911 and 1913 by James Allison, a prominent entrepreneur and one of the founders of the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, this sprawling mansion was once a symbol of opulence and luxury. Designed in the Italian Renaissance style, it was Allison’s dream home.

James Allison Mansion - Credit mollyandmyrtle
James Allison Mansion – Credit mollyandmyrtle

Over the years, however, rumors and legends have emerged about the mansion being haunted. While there is no concrete evidence to support these claims, there are numerous accounts of mysterious happenings within the walls of the mansion. Some have reported hearing unexplained footsteps, voices, and even seeing apparitions.

One of the more popular legends involves the ghost of a maid who was said to have fallen in love with Allison and was heartbroken after being spurned. It is said that her ghost still roams the halls, looking for her unrequited love. Others claim to have seen the ghost of Allison himself, wandering the rooms and hallways of his former residence.

Today, the mansion is part of the Marian University campus and serves as an educational facility. Yet, the haunted allure of the James Allison Mansion persists, a testament to the power of folklore and the human imagination’s ability to transform an ordinary place into a site of mystery and wonder.

Whispers Estate, Mitchell

Whispers Estate is a Victorian mansion located in Mitchell, Indiana. Built in 1894, the mansion was originally owned by the John Gibbons family. The mansion was later converted into a hospital and orphanage, adding to the dark history of the house. The mansion is now known as one of the most haunted places in Indiana.

Whispers Estate, Mitchell - Credit carlij_photography
Whispers Estate, Mitchell – Credit carlij_photography

The house has a reputation for being haunted by the ghosts of children who died in the hospital and orphanage. The most famous ghost is that of Rachael, a young girl who died in the house. Visitors have reported hearing her giggling and playing in the halls. Others have reported seeing the apparition of a woman in a white dress, believed to be Mrs. Gibbons.

Whispers Estate offers ghost tours and paranormal investigations for those brave enough to explore the haunted mansion. Visitors have reported experiencing strange occurrences, such as doors opening and closing on their own, objects moving, and even feeling a presence touching them.

Overall, Whispers Estate is a must-visit destination for those interested in the paranormal and history. Visitors should be prepared for a spooky and unforgettable experience.

Hannah House, Indianapolis

Hannah House, also known as the Alexander Hannah House, is a stately red brick mansion located at 3801 Madison Avenue, Indianapolis, Indiana. It was built in 1858 by Alexander Hannah, a wealthy businessman who was a member of the Indiana State Legislature. The house has 24 rooms, two floors, an attic, and a basement, as well as a north two-story kitchen wing.

Hannah House, Indiana
Hannah House, Indiana

One of Indiana’s most spooky homes, The Hannah House has been the focus of countless paranormal investigations. The mansion is said to be haunted by the ghosts of former slaves who perished in a fire that started there during the Civil War. A group of slaves believed to be on the Underground Railroad is claimed to have perished at the Hannah House one night when an oil light malfunctioned and started a fire.

Despite its haunted reputation, the Hannah House is open to the public for tours and events. Visitors can explore the house and learn about its history and paranormal activity. The Hannah House is also a popular location for ghost hunts and other paranormal investigations. If you’re brave enough, you can even spend the night in the house and see if you encounter any ghosts or spirits.

Culbertson Mansion

The Culbertson Mansion is a historic home located in New Albany, Indiana. Built in the late 1800s by William Culbertson, it is known for its intriguing history and otherworldly residents. The mansion has been the subject of numerous paranormal investigations and is believed to be haunted by several ghosts.

The cost of building the Culbertson Mansion was $120,000 during that time. Witnesses have reported hearing doors shut by themselves and footsteps upstairs while no one is up there. The mansion has a way of drawing people in, whether they are here for the history or Culbertson’s haunted past.

Every year, nonprofit organization Friends of the Culbertson Mansion, Inc. hosts “Literally, A Haunted House,” the mansion’s biggest annual fundraiser. The event features live actors, special effects, and terrifying scenes that are sure to scare even the bravest of visitors.

Despite its haunted reputation, the Culbertson Mansion is still a popular tourist destination. Visitors can take a guided tour of the mansion and learn about its rich history, including its connection to the Underground Railroad. The mansion is also available for private events, such as weddings and corporate functions.

Overall, the Culbertson Mansion is an intriguing and spooky place to visit for those who are interested in the paranormal or just enjoy a good scare. Its rich history and haunting past make it a must-visit destination for anyone traveling to Indiana.

Willard Library

Willard Library is one of the most famous haunted houses in Indiana. Located in Evansville, the library is said to be haunted by a ghost known as the Grey Lady. The Grey Lady is believed to be the ghost of Louise Carpenter, the daughter of the library’s founder.

The library was built in 1885 and has a stunning Italian Gothic architecture. The Grey Lady is often seen on the second floor of the library, and her presence is said to be felt throughout the building. Many visitors have reported seeing her apparition, and some have even claimed to have seen her move books or turn pages.

Willard Library - Credit Indiana Landmarks
Willard Library – Credit Indiana Landmarks

In addition to the Grey Lady, there have been reports of other ghostly activity at the library. Visitors have reported hearing strange noises, feeling cold spots, and seeing books move on their own. Some have even reported seeing the ghost of a man who is believed to be the library’s founder, Willard Carpenter.

Despite its haunted reputation, Willard Library is still open to the public and offers a wide range of services and programs. Visitors can browse the library’s extensive collection of books, attend events and workshops, and even take a ghost tour of the building.

Overall, Willard Library is a must-visit for anyone interested in the paranormal. Whether you’re a believer or a skeptic, the library’s haunted history is sure to send chills down your spine.

The Story Inn – Nashville, Indiana

The Story Inn, located in Nashville, Indiana, is known as one of the most haunted places in the Midwest. It is Indiana’s oldest country inn, built in 1851 as a community for logging. The town of Story grew steadily until the Great Depression, which led to its decline.

The inn’s current owner was once a skeptic, but after taking over the business, he now knows for sure that the inn is haunted. One of the first things he noticed was that most rooms had one guestbook each, where guests were asked to write any bizarre and spooky experiences they might have had during their stay. The inn has kept countless records of hauntings occurring at the property, written by guests in these guestbooks.

Many of the stories go back to the sighting of a ghost known as the “Blue Lady.” She is said to be the ghost of a woman who died in the inn’s honeymoon suite after her husband left her on their wedding night. The Blue Lady is often seen wandering the halls, and some guests have reported seeing her in their rooms.

Aside from the Blue Lady, guests have reported other paranormal activity at the inn, including unexplained noises, doors opening and closing on their own, and strange smells. Some guests have even reported feeling a presence in their room, as if someone was watching them.

Despite its haunted reputation, the Story Inn is a popular destination for tourists and ghost hunters alike. The inn offers a unique and spooky experience for those brave enough to stay the night.

The Roads Hotel, Atlanta

The Roads Hotel, located in Atlanta, Indiana, is one of the most famous haunted houses in the state. The hotel was built in 1893 by Abraham Kauffman and has a long and fascinating history. It has been a hotel, a brothel, a speakeasy during the prohibition era, and a restaurant.

The hotel is said to be haunted by several ghosts, including a little girl named Emma, who is often seen playing in the lobby. There are also reports of a ghostly woman in a white dress who is seen walking through the halls. Guests have reported hearing strange noises, feeling cold spots, and seeing objects move on their own.

The hotel has been investigated by several paranormal groups, and many believe that it is one of the most haunted places in Indiana. The hotel has been featured on several TV shows, including Ghost Adventures and Paranormal Lockdown.

Despite its haunted reputation, the Roads Hotel is still open to the public. Guests can stay overnight in one of the hotel’s haunted rooms or visit for a meal at the restaurant. The hotel also offers ghost tours and paranormal investigations for those who are interested in the supernatural.

Overall, the Roads Hotel is a fascinating and spooky destination for anyone interested in the paranormal. Whether you believe in ghosts or not, the hotel’s rich history and eerie atmosphere make it a must-visit location in Indiana.


Indiana is home to many haunted houses with a rich history and plenty of ghostly activity. From the James Allison Mansion to the Roads Hotel, there is no shortage of spooky places to visit in Indiana.

Visitors to Indiana’s haunted houses should be prepared for a truly terrifying experience. Many of these locations have been investigated by paranormal experts and have been featured in popular television shows, such as Ghost Adventures and Paranormal Lockdown.

For those brave enough to venture inside, Indiana’s haunted houses offer a unique opportunity to explore the supernatural world. Who knows what you might encounter on your visit? If you have any suggestions on other Haunted Places in Indiana, let us know in the comments.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous Post

Haunted Places in Washington DC: A Guide to the City’s Spookiest Locations

Next Post

Unveiling the Mysteries: Exploring Haunted Places in Manhattan

New York Public Library, Stephen A. Schwarzman Building