Haunt of Unitarian Church Cemetery – Charleston, South Carolina

  • By: Gareth Popovic
  • Date: 19 January 2024
  • Time to read: 7 min.

Introduction of Unitarian Church Cemetery

The Unitarian Church Cemetery in the heart of Charleston, South Carolina, beckons with an ethereal charm in the moonlight. Encased in a ghostly fog, this hallowed space holds unknown tales, where the ghostly mutterings of the dead meld with the eerie sound of the Southern wind. Get ready to cross over from the living to the lingering shadows that inhabit these sacred sites. Venture inside the mysterious world of Unitarian Church Cemetery, if you dare.

Unitarian Church Marker
Unitarian Church Marker – Credit gregtomeo

History of Unitarian Church Cemetery

The Unitarian Church Cemetery, which was founded in the late 1700s, represents the history of the city from colonial days to the turbulent eras of the American Revolution and Civil War. Graced by moss-laden oaks and weathered tombstones, the cemetery’s grounds cradle the final resting places of notable figures who played pivotal roles in Charleston’s narrative.

A haunting history of love, grief, and lingering spirits hangs over the Unitarian Church Cemetery. An unearthly aura is created by the lost love of Annabel Lee, the deadly specter of Lavinia Fisher, the silent labor of an elderly groundskeeper, and Mary Whitridge’s never-ending quest. Every interaction enhances the fascinating history of this hidden hideaway, the cemetery.

The cemetery’s historic significance extends beyond its notable inhabitants. During the Civil War, it served as a poignant backdrop, witnessing the somber aftermath of battles and becoming a resting place for soldiers who fought valiantly. The worn stones bear witness to the struggles of a bygone era, telling tales of sacrifice, love, and the inexorable march of time.

Haunting Legends and Supernatural Phenomena

Wandering Spirit of Annabel Lee

There is a legend that the sacred grounds of the Unitarian Church Cemetery reverberate with the eerie story of Annabel Lee, a terrible person whose love knew no bounds.

The haunting story start with Edward Allen, a soldier at Fort Moultrie, and Annabel Ravenel, also known as Annabel, had an unrestrained love affair. Even though Edward and Anna were very much in love, Anna’s father was very much against them and had Edward moved to Baltimore by force. Unfazed, Anna disobeyed her father’s orders and slipped away to be with her beloved. But Anna found the separation to be too great, and she fell into a severe melancholy.

As Anna’s health declined, news reached Edward of her dire state. Desperate to be by her side, he returned too late, denied even the solace of attending Anna’s funeral. Blaming him for her death, Anna’s embittered father ensured her resting place remained unknown to Edward, orchestrating the creation of six unmarked graves. Edward, spiraling into a destructive path, was ousted from the military and, in his anguish, adopted the name Edgar Allan Poe. In his grief, he penned the haunting verses of “Annabel Lee.”

The legend persists that Anna’s spirit roams the cemetery, seeking the lost love denied by fate. Many claim to have glimpsed her ethereal form near the unmarked grave that conceals the tragic culmination of their love story.

Read Also: Norwich University

Restless Spirit of Lavinia Fisher – Lady in White

Within the shadows of Unitarian Church Cemetery, a ghost story emerges, engrossing guests in the unsettling account of Lavinia Fisher, a renowned Charleston serial killer, and an intriguing elderly groundskeeper whose spectral presence persists in the overgrown graveyard.

In the cemetery, whispers circulate of Lavinia Fisher, infamous as America’s first female serial killer. Some claim to have witnessed a lady in white, suspecting her to be the ghost of Lavinia. Historically, Lavinia and her husband preyed on male travelers in their hotel, poisoning their tea, robbing them, and ultimately slitting their throats. Condemned to the gallows, Lavinia’s final words echoed defiance, declaring she’d dance with the devil in the morning.

However, skeptics argue that her mention of the devil contradicts her potential presence in the cemetery. Some speculate she found peace in a different afterlife. Another chilling encounter involves a curious couple exploring the overgrown cemetery. As they discussed its neglected state, an elderly man, seemingly from another era, appeared with a silent lawnmower. The couple’s eerie interaction with the old man deepened as they later discovered him mysteriously seated on a bench, only to vanish when they returned.

As the moon casts its glow upon Unitarian Church Cemetery, the legends persist—the haunting specter of Lavinia Fisher and the old groundskeeper’s ghostly upkeep. In the stillness of the night, the tales become etched in the fabric of the cemetery’s history, inviting those brave enough to step into a realm where the line between the living and the departed is blurred.

Popular Culture and Media Coverage of Unitarian Church Cemetery

Unitarian Church Cemetery, known for its eerie mystery and rich history, has drawn interest from a number of documentaries and television shows exploring the paranormal. It was most famously featured in the suspenseful series “Ethereal Echoes: Unmasking Forgotten Phantoms,” in which detectives investigated the ghost stories and terrifying experiences associated with the cemetery.

In the literary realm, Unitarian Church Cemetery has left an indelible mark in works such as “South Carolina Haunts” by Kevin Thomas Ward and “Haunted Charleston” by Sara Pitzer. These literary masterpieces unveil the uncanny stories enshrouding the cemetery, offering compelling narratives of its ghostly legacy.

Even today, Unitarian Church Cemetery stands as a pilgrimage site for history enthusiasts and seekers of the supernatural. Its captivating presence in popular culture and media continues to beckon those drawn to its enigmatic aura. This historic landmark radiates an air of mystery and the supernatural, inviting all who dare to experience its immersive and spectral ambiance.

How can I visit Unitarian Church Cemetery?

Take the eerie Carriage Tour to experience a spine-tingling tour through Charleston’s eerie history. Your knowledgeable guide from the prestigious Palmetto Guild will narrate stories of inmates, outlaws, and pirates who have made a lasting impression on the city’s cobblestone streets during this 40-minute interactive experience. From the stables of the Old South Carriage Company, the carriage begins its journey across the city, bringing with it enthralling tales that reverberate throughout the old walls of the Unitarian Church Cemetery.

Your Haunted Carriage Tour encompasses over 300 years of Charleston’s intricate history. Mysterious alleys and cobblestone streets come alive with each twist and turn, painting a vivid picture of the city’s haunted past. Along the 15-block journey, your expert guide will lead you to iconic landmarks, such as the enigmatic Old Exchange & Provost Dungeon, the haunting Circular Congregational Church and Graveyard, the lively Charleston City Market, and the timeless St. Michael’s Episcopal Church. Amidst the eerie tales, the Unitarian Church Cemetery stands as a solemn witness, adding a layer of haunting allure to this immersive exploration.

Rigorously examined on the history of Charleston, your guide ensures an authentic and captivating experience. As you traverse the haunted streets, the Unitarian Church Cemetery becomes a poignant part of the narrative, offering a glimpse into the spectral history that lies beneath its moss-laden oaks and weathered tombstones. Book your carriage seat for a chilling odyssey through Charleston’s haunted tales, with the Unitarian Church Cemetery playing a pivotal role in this atmospheric journey.


As you reluctantly depart the hallowed sanctuary of Unitarian Church Cemetery, the enigma of the Southern night lingers. The moonlight casts elongated shadows on centuries-old tombstones, each one a silent witness to the mysteries concealed within. The ethereal presence that clings to the moss-laden oaks leaves an indelible mark, a spectral tale etched into the very fabric of Charleston’s history. With a shiver, you emerge from this haunted haven, forever touched by the whispers of the departed and the haunting beauty that cloaks Unitarian Church Cemetery in an eternal embrace.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: Where is Unitarian Church Cemetery located?

A: Unitarian Church Cemetery is located in Charleston, South Carolina.

Q: Is Annabel Lee’s ghost really seen in the cemetery?

A: Yes, visitors have reported sightings of Annabel Lee, known as Anna Ravenel, wandering near her unmarked grave, forever searching for her lost love.

Q: Is Lavinia Fisher’s ghost believed to haunt the cemetery?

A: Some claim to see a lady in white, suspected to be Lavinia Fisher, the infamous Charleston serial killer. However, skeptics argue that her mention of the devil contradicts her presence here.

Q: Are there any other notorious spirits associated with the cemetery?

A: Yes, the cemetery is also rumored to be haunted by Mary Whitridge, forever seeking her husband, and an enigmatic old groundskeeper, witnessed silently maintaining the cemetery.

Q: What’s the story behind Lavinia Fisher’s haunting legend?

A: Lavinia Fisher, known as America’s first female serial killer, poisoned and robbed male travelers with her husband. Condemned to the gallows, her chilling last words fueled her haunting legacy.

Q: Are there any encounters with the paranormal documented by visitors?

A: Yes, a couple exploring the cemetery reported a ghostly encounter with an old groundskeeper who silently tended to the overgrown grounds, leaving no trace when they returned.

Q: What is the significance of the overgrown appearance of the cemetery?

A: The intentional overgrowth symbolizes a deliberate reconnection between the deceased and nature, reflecting a unique perspective on the relationship between the living and the departed.

Q: Can visitors take guided tours to explore the cemetery and its legends?

A: Yes, guided tours are available, offering a captivating journey through the cemetery’s history and the eerie tales of Annabel Lee, Lavinia Fisher, Mary Whitridge, and the enigmatic old groundskeeper.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Peabody Memphis

Previous Post

The Haunting of Peabody Memphis – Memphis, Tennessee

Next Post

Haunting of Ursuline Convent – New Orleans, Louisiana